House rules
Community Guidelines
Be lively. Be funny. Be opinionated. Be the person at the bar after service, not the person who keys a car in the parking lot.
Last updated
November 2026
November 2026
Fair game
- Published reviews, columns, rankings and broadcasts.
- Editorial judgments: what they praised, what they panned, what they missed.
- Professional qualifications and expertise, as shown in the work.
- Public statements made in a professional capacity.
- Disagreeing with us. Defending the critic. Telling us our roast is lazy.
Off the menu
- Threats, intimidation, or wishing harm on anyone.
- Doxxing: addresses, phone numbers, workplaces beyond the byline, family members, photos of private life.
- Discriminatory abuse based on race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation, disability, age or any protected characteristic.
- Invented allegations: claims of misconduct you can’t link to a public source.
- Private life: health, relationships, appearance, personal finances.
- Impersonating a critic, a chef, a restaurant, or us.
- Spam, self-promotion and coordinated vote campaigns.
How moderation works
At launch, every comment is read by an editor before it appears. Anyone with a verified account can report a published comment. Reported comments are reviewed, and removed if they break these rules. Every moderation action is logged.
Repeated or serious violations get an account restricted: no commenting, and its votes stop counting. We don’t announce restrictions and we don’t debate them in the comments.
A simple test
Would this comment still make sense if the critic had never published a word? If yes, it’s about the person, not the work, and it doesn’t belong here.