Standards
Editorial Policy
November 2026
1. The inaugural order is opinion
The first Top 10 is a provisional editorial ranking: our subjective view of published work, in our order. It is not a statistical result, a survey, or a determination of anyone’s professional competence. We label it as editorial wherever it appears, and we keep the original editorial rank on file separately from the community rank.
2. Satire versus fact
Everything on a critic’s page falls into one of three categories, and we keep them visibly apart:
- The Roast is satire and opinion. Exaggeration is the point. It must be about published professional work and must not imply undisclosed facts.
- The Receipts are factual. Each one names a specific published review, column or public statement, links to it, and gives a date where known. Context, including the critic’s own response, is included where relevant.
- Profile facts (city, publication, background) are shown only after an editor has verified them against the public record. Until then the page says “to be verified”.
3. What we won’t publish
- Invented quotations, controversies, biographical details or allegations.
- Anything about private life: health, family, relationships, home, finances, appearance or protected characteristics.
- Fabricated votes, comments, engagement figures, testimonials or star ratings, in the page or in structured data.
4. Sourcing
A receipt can’t be published without a working link to the original and an editor’s verification stamp. The database enforces this; it isn’t just a promise. Paywalled sources are allowed if they’re the original. Unverified items stay unpublished.
5. How community scoring works
Verified account holders can cast one active vote per critic: Rotten or Not Rotten. Votes can be changed or withdrawn. Totals are public; individual votes never are.
A raw percentage rewards tiny samples: two Rotten votes would make 100%. So we rank by the lower bound of the Wilson score interval (95% confidence) on each critic’s Rotten share. It asks: given these votes, what’s the lowest Rotten share we can be reasonably confident in? Small samples get pulled toward caution.
Example: 2 of 2 votes Rotten scores 0.342. 180 of 200 scores 0.851. The second critic ranks higher, as they should.
A critic needs at least 50 votes to be eligible for the community ranking. The community Top 10 replaces the editorial order automatically once 10 critics are eligible. Until then the editorial order is shown, clearly labelled. Votes from accounts restricted for abuse are excluded from all totals.
6. Corrections
Report errors through the corrections desk. We correct factual errors promptly and note the change on the page. Opinion isn’t an error, but a correction to a fact the opinion rests on may change the opinion, and we’ll rewrite accordingly.
7. Right of reply
Any featured critic may submit a response. After we confirm identity, it runs in full on their page, visually distinct from reader comments. We don’t edit replies for substance.
8. Nominations
Nominated critics are never published automatically. An editor must confirm a genuine public record of restaurant criticism before a profile is created. Nominators stay private.